Can Pakistan overcome new security challenges which are emanating from changing regional security landscape and internal discords?
Externally, Pakistan faces new security threats from impending perilous outcomes in Afghanistan, shifting global power dynamics with intensifying US-China power competition, growing Indo-US strategic partnership, changing nature and characteristics of the Indian state, advancing technology and cyber threats, navigating new geopolitics of the region, and emerging transboundary terrorism challenges.
If Afghanistan descends into chaos because of the looming humanitarian crisis, it will create security challenges for Pakistan. The fallout of Afghanistan’s humanitarian crisis can be refugee influx in the KPK and Balochistan, which have already been volatile provinces of the country. The more Afghan exodus reaches these two provinces, the greater economic pain will be felt. Consequently, conflict escalates over meagre resources—especially water and food—between different segments of society, creating a new theatre of contest in both provinces of the country. Moreover, the Taliban’s takeover of Afghanistan seems to have emboldened other extremist groups such as the TTP and the IS-K, impelling them to increase their terrorist activities in Pakistan, thereby disrupting hardly achieved internal peace and stability.
With the shifting of winds of power from West to East, Pakistan, owing to its geostrategic location, will find itself in the eye of the geopolitical storm of US-China power competition. Pakistan’s balancing approach toward the USA and China is no longer workable; it has to make a strategic choice between Washington and Beijing as both powers’ growing competition is compressing time and space for Islamabad. Obviously, by aligning with either of the two great powers, Pakistan will confront new security challenges because great powers can cloud the strategic environment of the region. The growing Indo-US strategic romance can greatly affect the regional strategic stability.
Both external and internal security threats deserve attention. Pakistan can overcome external challenges by crafting proactive foreign policy measures in order to protect its national interests. Pakistan’s geo-economic shift is a significant policy initiative that will help the country steering itself out of new geopolitical crises. Besides, appreciating diversity, getting rid of extremism, making equal distribution of resources, promoting democratic culture, and educating the youth can be panacea to these security challenges.
To contain China, the USA has forged a strategic alliance with India; both countries have increased their military collaboration. Despite nuclear deterrence, strategic balance in the region will tilt in favour of India provided that Washington throws its strategic weight behind New Delhi to obstruct Beijing’s regional outreach. As a result, Pakistan will be at disadvantaged position as the regional balance of power shifts against it, while India is radically transforming internally.
Notwithstanding India has claimed to be a secular and democratic country, power usurpation by the BJP-RSS cohort, with ultranationalist sentiments, has changed the nature and characteristics of the Indian state. The moderate and secular impulse of the country has stopped working; India is now becoming a dangerous radical country with increasing extremist tendencies in both the government and the media. This ideological change in India brought about the Pulwama/Balakot crisis, and has increased the risk of nuclear escalation between the two nuclear armed countries. Ideological shift in India, as has been taking place since the BJP has come to power, would have horrendous repercussions for regional peace. It increases the risk of strategic miscalculation by affecting crises as well as deterrence stability.
However, technological advancement is critical for modern development. But it has security implications, too. Artificial intelligence and cyber security advancement by adversaries put vulnerable countries at risk. India’s primacy in the IT sector creates national security challenges for Pakistan because New Delhi attempts to use its technological superiority to carry out cyberattacks against Islamabad. Critical communication networks will be disrupted that certainly result in the breach of national security data by putting all security installations, banking systems and information sectors at risk. Besides, information warfare and cyberterrorism are also woven into the global technological landscape.
Moreover, shifting sands of regional geopolitics puts stress on the country’s national security. Navigating these troubled waters will not be as smooth as it seems since geopolitical transformation is occurring in Pakistan’s neighbourhood and beyond. Militant groups at the helm of affairs in Afghanistan, Indo-US strategic alignment, Indo-Israel bonhomie, Saudi-Iran discontent, Arab normalization with Israel, great power competition at the Indo-Pacific region, Russia’s return to South Asia and China’s quest to be the next global superpower are critical developments which can be a litmus test for Pakistan’s national security.
Although Pakistan has succeeded in eliminating terrorist networks by launching several military operations in conflict-ridden areas of the country, terrorist outfits have flown to Afghanistan and other neighbouring countries from where they operate and carry out sporadic terrorist activities in Pakistan. Religious and nationalist banned militant organizations tend to launch attacks on Pakistani soil by hiding in neighbouring countries. Recent mounting terrorist activities in the country signify that new security threats are emerging from transboundary terrorist operations.
Internally, identity crisis, ethno-nationalism, extremism, deteriorating state-society relations, political polarization, contest over interprovincial water resources and socio-economic insecurity are critical challenges for the country’s national security. These challenges can stymie Pakistan’s economic progress and political stability which are crucial for internal cohesion and national harmony.
Both external and internal security threats deserve attention. Pakistan can overcome external challenges by crafting proactive foreign policy measures in order to protect its national interests. Pakistan’s geo-economic shift is a significant policy initiative that will help the country steering itself out of new geopolitical crises. Besides, appreciating diversity, getting rid of extremism, making equal distribution of resources, promoting democratic culture, and educating the youth can be panacea to these security challenges.
