The controversy about the prohibited Foreign Funding case against PTI pending with the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) took a new twist on Friday as a report by Financial Times has blown the lid off disgraced financier Arif Naqvi’s involvement in the party’s finances and how a significant portion of its funding in 2013 was of foreign origin.
According to the report, “Naqvi transferred three instalments directly to the PTI in 2013 adding up to a total of $2.12m”.
At the centre of the saga is Wootton Cricket Ltd, a Cayman Islands-incorporated company owned by Naqvi, and the money from charity fundraisers, such as the “Wootton T20 Cup”, to bankroll PTI.
Naqvi, the founder of the Dubai-based Abraaj Group, one of the largest private equity firms operating in emerging markets back when the PTI was campaigning for the 2013 elections, hosted the cricket tournament at his country estate in the Oxfordshire village of Wootton from 2010 to 2012, FT said.
The guests were asked to pay between £2,000 and £2,500 each to attend, according to the UK publication. Quoting, Naqvi, it added that the money went to unspecified “philanthropic causes”.
“Funds poured into Wootton Cricket from companies and individuals, including at least £2m from a United Arab Emirates government minister who is also a member of the Abu Dhabi royal family,” read the FT report.
Political parties in Pakistan are not permitted to receive funding from foreign nationals and companies, but Wootton Cricket account details and emails seen by FT for the period between February 28 and May 30, 2013, reveal that both companies and foreign nationals, as well as Pakistanis, sent millions of dollars to Wootton Cricket after which funds were transferred to the PTI in Pakistan.
The ECP had been probing the party’s funding since 2014, when party founder Akbar S Babar alleged major irregularities in the party’s finances, including in funding from outside Pakistan.
ECP has now concluded the case after seven years of trial. The date the verdict will be announced is yet to be revealed.
In January, the ECP’s scrutiny committee issued a damning report in which it said the PTI received funding from foreign nationals and companies. The report said the PTI under-reported funds and hid dozens of bank accounts. Wootton Cricket was named in the report, but Naqvi had not been identified as its owner.
Also, while it was previously reported that Naqvi funded Khan’s party, the ultimate source of the money was never before disclosed.
“Wootton Cricket’s bank statement shows it received $1.3m on March 14 2013 from Abraaj Investment Management Ltd, the fund management unit of Naqvi’s private equity firm, boosting the account’s previous balance of $5,431. Later the same day, $1.3m was transferred from the account directly to a PTI bank account in Pakistan. Abraaj expensed the cost to a holding company through which it controlled K-Electric, the power provider to Karachi, Pakistan’s largest city,” the FT report said.
An additional $2m flowed into the Wootton Cricket account in April 2013 from a member of Abu Dhabi’s royal family, according to the bank statement and a copy of the Swift transfer details seen by FT.
“Naqvi then exchanged emails with a colleague about transferring $1.2m more to the PTI. Six days after the $2m arrived in the Wootton Cricket bank account, Naqvi transferred $1.2m from it to Pakistan in two instalments,” according to FT.
The report said that Rafique Lakhani, the senior Abraaj executive responsible for managing cash flow, “wrote in an email to Naqvi that the transfers were intended for the PTI”.
Naqvi and his lawyer did not respond to FT’s requests for comment on the story.
What does Khan have to say about all this?
Imran Khan visited Wootton Place in 2012. To questions by FT, the former cricketer wrote back saying he had gone to “a fundraising event which was attended by many PTI supporters”.
The FT report described the time as “critical” for Khan to collect funds ahead of the 2013 general elections due in May.
According to the publication, Naqvi worked closely with other Pakistani businessmen to raise money for his campaign.
Lakhani, the Abraaj executive responsible for cash flow, told Naqvi in an email that the money from UAE had arrived, to which Naqvi replied by saying that he should send “1.2 million to PTI”.
After the sheikh’s money was put into the Wootton Cricket account Naqvi wrote in another email: “do not tell anyone where funds are coming from, ie who is contributing”.
“Sure sir,” Lakhani responded.
According to the report, Lakhani “wrote that he would transfer $1.2m from Wootton Cricket to the PTI’s account in Pakistan”.
“Then after considering sending the funds to the PTI via Naqvi’s personal account, Lakhani proposed sending the money in two instalments to a personal account for businessman Tariq Shafi in Karachi and an account for an entity called the Insaf Trust in Lahore.
“Although the ownership of the Insaf Trust is unclear, the emails state that the final destination was the PTI,” read the report.
The FT report goes on to state that “on May 6 2013, Wootton Cricket transferred a total of $1.2m to Shafi and the Insaf Trust”.
According to FT, Khan confirmed that Shafi donated to the PTI. “It is for Tariq Shafi to answer as to from where he received this money,” Khan said. Shafi did not respond to FT’s requests for comment.
Khan said that neither he nor his party was aware of Abraaj providing $1.3m through Wootton Cricket. He also said he was “not aware” of the PTI receiving any funds that originated from UAE.
“Arif Naqvi has given a statement which was filed before the Election Commission also, not denied by anyone, that the money came from donations during a cricket match and the money as collected by him was sent through his company Wootton Cricket,” Khan wrote.
Khan said he was waiting for the ECP’s verdict and that it will be inappropriate to “prejudge PTI”.
In its January report, the ECP said Wootton Cricket had transferred $2.12m to the PTI but at the time did not reveal the original source of the money.
Naqvi denies wrongdoing
Naqvi has acknowledged his ownership of Wootton Cricket and denied any wrongdoing. He told the ECP: “I have not collected any fund from any person of non-Pakistani origin, company [public or private] or any other prohibited source.”
But the Wootton Cricket bank statement shows otherwise. It shows that Naqvi transferred three instalments directly to the PTI in 2013 adding up to a total of $2.12m. The largest was the $1.3mn from Abraaj which company documents show was transferred to Wootton Cricket but charged to its holding company for K-Electric.
Imran Khan, his foreign funding ‘biggest threat’ to country: Marriyum
Reacting to the FT story, Minister for Information and Broadcasting Marriyum Aurangzeb said Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) Cheif Imran Khan and the foreign funding received by his party were the “biggest threat” to the country.
“Currently, the country is facing a major security threat from Imran Khan,” she said in a news release while reacting to the PTI chief’s statement.
She said the person (Imran), who had received funding from the United States, had no right to talk on the national security. Instead of discussing the economy, Imran Khan should answer as to why he used the donations for running his party’s affairs, she added.
The minister asked Imran Khan to “shut his mouth” as he had already weakened the national economy and security. Imran Khan, while being in power, appeased his “foreign funders” by destabilising the country and selling the Kashmir cause, she alleged.
She claimed that the PTI chairman had been fulfilling demands of his foreign funders since 2011. He also met the “demands of his foreign funders by weakening the country and economy, starving the people and gagging the media”, she added.
Imran Khan traded off the Kashmir for foreign funding, the minister claimed. She said it did not suit to Imran Khan to lecture the current government as it was he who did not get response from the foreign leaders despite several attempts.
PTI accepts receiving funds from Naqvi
The PTI Friday accepted that it had received funds from Pakistani businessman Arif Naqvi’s Wootton Cricket Ltd — a Cayman Islands-incorporated company — after a foreign publication reported that its donations were of foreign origin.
“All the records [related to those transactions] are available,” PTI Central Deputy Secretary Information Farrukh Habib told a press conference after a Financial Times report revealed that Naqvi “transferred three instalments directly to the PTI in 2013 adding up to a total of $2.12m” — which were of foreign origin.
The PTI leader said that there was no case against Naqvi or his Abraaj Group in 2012 and that the businessman had given £20 million to PML-N supremo Nawaz Sharif and his brother, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, in “bribes”.
In his press conference Friday, Farrukh Habib said that a “media trial” is conducted against the party every now and then related to foreign funding.
“The case against PTI is not related to foreign funding, rather it is of prohibited funding […] foreign funds are used for working against an incumbent government; that’s not the case here,” he said.
He said that his party laid the foundation of funding in Pakistan. He added that overseas Pakistanis send $32 billion annually to the country and they also donate them to PTI.
He reiterated that the verdicts of PTI, PPP, and PML-N’s foreign funding cases be issued on the same date as he demanded that the ECP demonstrate responsible behaviour.
The PTI leader claimed that the PML-N hid 112 accounts from the election commission, PPP hid 11 and did not give records of Rs3.6 million to the ECP.
